IMHE OpenIR  > 数字山地与遥感应用中心
Alternative TitleIntercomparison and evaluation of influencing factors among different LAI products over mountainous areas
景金城1,2,3; 靳华安1; 唐斌2; 李爱农1
Source Publication自然资源学报
Contribution Rank1
Abstract叶面积指数(LAI)遥感产品对比分析不仅能够提供产品质量的定量化描述信息,还对产品反演算法优化和认知陆面过程模型的不确定性具有重要意义。为研究不同LAI产品在地形复杂、景观破碎的中国西南地区的表现差异,选择2001-2016年间MODIS(C5、C6)和Geoland2(GEOV1、GEOV2)LAI产品,从时空完整性和连续性方面,对比分析不同LAI产品在山区的变化情况,并比较同源不同版本LAI产品在山区的改进效果。选择地形(如高程、地形起伏度)、植被类型、气候因子,使用地理探测器评估LAI遥感产品受不同下垫面的影响程度。结果表明:(1)高海拔和高地形起伏度区域LAI产品质量较差;(2)MODIS LAI产品连续性整体性差于 Geoland2,MODIS LAI均值在局部地区高于Geoland2,同源产品LAI差值低于非同源产品;(3)MODIS C6主算法反演比例低于C5,时间连续性优于C5,GEOV2反演成功率和连续性优于 GEOV1;(4)各因子对山区LAI变化的贡献量q:地形起伏度最小,MODIS产品受植被类型影响最大,Geoland2产品受高程和气象数据影响较大。通过LAI产品对比分析,能够准确认知山区各因素对LAI产品精度的影响程度,可为山区生产高质量的LAI产品提供借鉴。
Other AbstractThe validation of LAI products not only provides quantitative quality description,but also plays an important part in the improvement of retrieval algorithm and understanding of uncertainties regarding to land surface process models over rugged surfaces.This study evaluated the performance of MODIS (C5,C6),Geoaldn2 (GEOV1,GEOV2)LAI products using intercomparison methods over Southwestern China.The spatiotemporal distribution of integrity and consistencies,such as the percentage of main algorithm,smoothness index,average value during growing season,yearly mean LAI bias and root mean square error(RMSE),respectively,were investigated during the period 2001-2016.Meanwhile,different versions of the same data source LAI products were compared so as to get a clear understanding of improvement about the new one over heterogeneously hilly regions.Lastly,four factors,such as topography (altitude and relief amplitude),vegetation types,and climate regionalization were selected to assess the influence of different underlying surfaces on LAI products using the Geodetector.The results show that spatial and temporal consistency of these LAI products is good over most areas.All LAI products exhibit a higher percentage of good quality data (i.e.successful retrieval)in mountainous areas,and GEOV2 LAI is higher than others.The percentage in altitude and higher relief amplitude area seems to be low.GEOV2 LAI shows smoother temporal profiles than others,and Geoland2 is smoother than MODIS LAI.It is clear that MODIS C5 is smoother than MODIS C6,and GEOV2 is superior to GEOV1.RMSE and yearly mean LAI bias between one and another LAI product are vulnerable to topographic indices,especially to altitude.Q-statistic in Geodetector is smallest related to relief amplitude,biggest to vegetation for MODIS LAI product,and biggest to climate for Geoland2 LAI.Altitude,vegetation,and climate play a dominant role in spatial distribution of LAI.The validation experience demonstrates the importance of topography,vegetation and climate for LAI estimation over mountainous areas.Considerable attention will be paid to the production of higher quality LAI products in topographically complex terrain.
Keyword叶面积指数 西南地区 对比分析 地理探测器 空间异质性
Indexed ByCSCD
Citation statistics
Cited Times:4[CSCD]   [CSCD Record]
Document Type期刊论文
Corresponding Author李爱农
First Author Affilication中国科学院水利部成都山地灾害与环境研究所
Corresponding Author Affilication中国科学院水利部成都山地灾害与环境研究所
Recommended Citation
GB/T 7714
景金城,靳华安,唐斌,等. 山区LAI遥感产品对比分析及影响因子评价[J]. 自然资源学报,2019,34(2):400-411.
APA 景金城,靳华安,唐斌,&李爱农.(2019).山区LAI遥感产品对比分析及影响因子评价.自然资源学报,34(2),400-411.
MLA 景金城,et al."山区LAI遥感产品对比分析及影响因子评价".自然资源学报 34.2(2019):400-411.
Files in This Item:
File Name/Size DocType Version Access License
山区LAI遥感产品对比分析及影响因子评价(5037KB)期刊论文出版稿开放获取CC BY-NC-SAView Application Full Text
Related Services
Recommend this item
Usage statistics
Export to Endnote
Google Scholar
Similar articles in Google Scholar
[景金城]'s Articles
[靳华安]'s Articles
[唐斌]'s Articles
Baidu academic
Similar articles in Baidu academic
[景金城]'s Articles
[靳华安]'s Articles
[唐斌]'s Articles
Bing Scholar
Similar articles in Bing Scholar
[景金城]'s Articles
[靳华安]'s Articles
[唐斌]'s Articles
Terms of Use
No data!
Social Bookmark/Share
File name: 山区LAI遥感产品对比分析及影响因子评价_景金城.pdf
Format: Adobe PDF
All comments (0)
No comment.

Items in the repository are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.